Ruling may have sweeping implications for search engines.
Published:
21 December 1999 y., Tuesday
In a case that may have sweeping implications for search engines of all kinds, a federal judge in California has ruled that a "visual search engine" did not violate copyright laws by collecting thumbnail images of photographs from the Web and displaying them on its site. The necessity of searching the Internet outweighed any other factor in determining whether a copyright was violated, the judge said.
In January, a California photographer sued Ditto.com, then known as the Arriba Vista Image Searcher, for violating her copyright by collecting and displaying 35 of her copyrighted images on its site as search results. The Ditto search engine works by "spidering" the Web - having a computer program collect some two million images from any site on the Internet it can find them - then shrinking each image down to a thumbnail image that is displayed in the search result.
The photographer argued that an image is an image and displaying her copyrighted photographs without her permission - and making money in the process - was effectively stealing.
The U.S. District Court judge in Santa Ana, Calif. ruled that Ditto wasn_t stealing the images. But the 15-page decision, handed down late Thursday, was somewhat more complicated - with the judge effectively giving a split decision on many of the relevant issues. However the judge said that the crucial role search engines serve for users of the Internet outweighs the other factors and makes Ditto_s thumbnails "fair use" of the images.
Copying, publishing, announcing any information from the News.lt portal without written permission of News.lt editorial office is prohibited.
The most popular articles
Software company announced new structure_ of it_s business.
more »
All Bulgarians possessing debit or credit cards will have to replace them with new "plastic purses" in 2005
more »
search.lt presents newest links
more »
search.lt presents newest links
more »
Security events recorded between July and September this year are up 150 per cent on those recorded by security company VeriSign in the same period last year
more »
search.lt presents newest links
more »
Banks partner with popular brands to promote credit cards
more »
SWsoft, a company that lets a Linux server be subdivided into independent partitions, is ready to begin testing a Windows version of its product
more »
Some Estonians will be able to vote online next year, as Tallinn plans trials with electronic voting software that is the first step toward a nationwide e-voting system
more »
search.lt presents newest links
more »
A Web site used by a Chechen warlord to claim responsibility for last month's school siege in Russia has come back online based out of Finland
more »