Napster can play on, but threat looms

Published: 22 February 2001 y., Thursday
A three- member panel of judges from the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco stopped short of immediately halting the music swapping, as a lower court had done in July. Calling the earlier decision by U.S. District Judge Marilyn Hall Patel "overbroad," they sent it back to the district court with instructions for creating a narrower injunction that would still require Napster to block the trading of copyrighted music. But the judges also warned that Napster could be liable for huge damages, which could lead to sweeping changes in the way it operates its service. "We affirm the district court's conclusion that plaintiffs have demonstrated a likelihood of success on the merits of the contributory copyright claim," the judges wrote. Some form of injunction is "not only warranted but required," the judges continued. That means Napster must halt the trading of specific files it is told to block by record companies. But that could be millions of songs, and it sets the stage for new, sweeping restrictions on what can be traded through the service. The ultimate fate of the controversial technology may hinge on whether it is possible--or impossible--to effectively police on thelabyrinthine networks created by file-swapping software. Monday's appellate court ruling ordered Napster to police its networks "within the limits of the system." As it has in the past, Napster will likely argue in its next appeal that it is technologically impossible to conduct this policing at the massive level demanded by the recording studios.
Šaltinis: two.digital.cnet.com
Copying, publishing, announcing any information from the News.lt portal without written permission of News.lt editorial office is prohibited.

Facebook Comments

New comment


Captcha

Associated articles

Antiwar hacker strikes the U.S. Navy

Virus writer and hacker activity has stepped up dramatically since the U.S. and U.K. armed forces started their war against Iraq more »

EU bigwig bangs on about eGovt

A top EU commissioner has been banging on about the importance of eGovernment more »

Al Jazeera launches English service

But within hours, firm suffers denial of service attack more »

Chip cards - in Kazakh practice

Commercial Alliance-Bank will be the first among RK banks implementing a transaction through international chip cards "Visa Smart Debit & Credit (VSDC)" through single processing center more »

A new Internet site

All those interested in British-Polish economic issues now have a new Internet site www.bpcc.org.pl more »

"Tibo’2003"

Minsk to Welcome Belarusian Congress on Telecommunications, Information and Banking Technologies more »

E-Russia threatened by cuts in financing

A drop in federal funding could delay some projects under the Electronic Russia program, which aims to boost the use of information technology throughout the country, the Communications Ministry said Tuesday more »

Belgian consortium heads race to run .eu

The European Commission is consulting its 15 national member governments over a draft decision to pick a Belgian-led consortium to run the long-awaited .eu top-level domain name registry more »

U.S. military computer attacked

Previously undiscovered flaw used to attack Army Web site more »

Banking Solutions at CeBIT 2003

Wincor Nixdorf presents a range of propositions with the spotlight focused on the specific needs and problems facing the banking industry under the key headings of Branch, Multichannel and Cash Management more »