It was a ruling that pleased free speech advocates and ticked off porn legislation activists.
Published:
7 January 2000 y., Friday
A California judge has dismissed a felony charge against a former teacher charged with trying to seduce a teenage boy over the Internet, adding one more argument to the debate swirling over riminalizing porn on the Net.
On Monday, Contra Costa Superior Court Judge John Minney declared unconstitutional a Penal Code section that makes it illegal to send sexual material over the Net if the sender knows the recipient is a minor, according to articles in the Contra Costa Times and the Recorder.
Many free speech advocates were pleased about the ruling and its implications for continued freedom of speech on the Net. But advocates of federal anti-porn laws said that free speech advocates are simply missing the point by allowing criminals to get off in the name of the First Amendment.
Edwin Wheelock, a former middle school teacher, was charged with one count of sending harmful material over the Net with intention to seduce a minor. Wheelock was arrested in April after being caught allegedly attempting to seduce a 14-year-old boy by chatting online and sending explicit photos to a police officer posing as a minor. But Judge Minney dismissed the charge, saying that the state law violated the
free speech and due process provisions of the First and 14th Amendments.
"The First Amendment guarantees us the right to speak and impart information to other people," Pierce said. "Porn is very vaguely defined. What constitutes pornography, you may not think is pornography. (Wheelock) is going to have to be tried under some other law. The state needs to craft another law that isn_t so vague."
The dismissal is the latest in a series of Net porn cases that have been thrown out because a judge ruled that federal laws governing sexual material and minors on the Net were unconstitutional.
Copying, publishing, announcing any information from the News.lt portal without written permission of News.lt editorial office is prohibited.
The most popular articles
EU animal welfare rules must be more rigorously enforced, with more inspections and effective penalties, said the Agriculture Committee on Wednesday.
more »
Fifty-three year old Rasima collects dirt everyday from a paddy field in Indonesia’s east Java province, turning it into a snack made entirely from soil, called "ampo."
more »
At the moment an Argentinian working for a French company in Spain can't travel to France for a meeting on his long-term visa.
more »
An EU-wide strategy is needed to combat violence against women, which must be recognised as a crime, said participants in a European Parliament public hearing with national parliaments and civil society representatives, held on Tuesday to mark International Women's Day.
more »
You know its Tet in Vietnam when Peach and Kumquat orange trees decorate every home, shop and public establishment.
more »
A surveyor has set up his tripod and instruments under a hot tropical sun to measure plots of land in a village where the Dac Kray minority community were settled four years ago.
more »
Japanese men are answering the call of Valentine s Day a month late.
more »
In three urgent resolutions adopted on Thursday, Parliament urges Hamas to release kidnapped Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit, deplores the escalating criminal violence in Mexico and calls on South Korea to scrap the death penalty.
more »
The plight of Europe's 10 million Roma population will fall under the spotlight Tuesday afternoon when MEPs discuss an upcoming Roman summit.
more »
EU Employment and Social Affairs Ministers have today adopted a Directive to prevent injuries and infections to healthcare workers from sharp objects such as needle sticks – one of the most serious health and safety threats in European workplaces and estimated to cause 1 million injuries each year.
more »