Minority protection in Europe: “a great paradox”

Published: 5 February 2009 y., Thursday

 

Europos Sąjungos valstybių narių vėliavos
MEPs believe “the right to speak and to be educated in one's mother tongue is one of the most basic fundamental rights” and on Tuesday Hungarian Socialist Csaba Tabajdi and five other MEPs grilled the Commission on its plans to protect traditional national, ethnic and immigrant minorities in Europe. We asked him more.

Mr Tabajdi heads the Parliament's national minority Intergroup, which has previously sponsored an EP resolution seeking to set the distinction between national and indigenous and ethnic/ migrant minorities.
 
How do the needs of traditional and ethnic minorities differ from those of immigrant ones?
 
About 8% of Europe's population belongs to indigenous and 6.5% to immigrant minorities - the latter mainly in Western Europe.

The difference is not in fundamental human liberties, as they must be ensured for all. The state should support indigenous or traditional ethnic minorities – who have been living on their territories for centuries – in their aspirations to preserve their mother tongue, culture, identity. (They should also speak the majority language of course.) In the case of immigrant minorities the state's obligation is different: it should help them integrate into society and learn the language of the host country.

 
Earlier you said: “Europe has always rewarded those minorities, which employ violence, instead of those using peaceful, constitutional means.”
 
These are the facts. There are very few examples to the contrary - perhaps Swedish-speaking Finns.

It does not however mean that I'd be in favour of violence. I believe that those minorities should be rewarded for their rights who have always fought by constitutional and peaceful means. Yet autonomy for some national minorities remains a taboo. This is one of the great paradoxes of minority protection in Europe.
 
At present, there is no legally binding system at EU level protecting traditional national minorities in Europe. Should there be one?
 
There is and there is not a European system of minority protection. In 1993, the European Council in Copenhagen set minority protection as one of the selection criteria for applicants to meet before they join...In other words, the 12 new members were required to meet the minority protection criteria, but the old members have not applied these to themselves.

If France or Greece sought admission to the EU today, they would not be accepted since neither has ratified the Council of Europe's two binding documents, which had to be ratified by all 12 newer Member States: the European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages and the Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities.


There is not a single reference to the existence of national minorities in the 80,000-page EU legislation: that's why the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty would be so important. It would for the first time provide a legally binding basis for the protection of minorities at EU level.

Šaltinis: europarl.europa.eu
Copying, publishing, announcing any information from the News.lt portal without written permission of News.lt editorial office is prohibited.

Facebook Comments

New comment


Captcha

Associated articles

The most popular articles

European Protection Order for victims under spotlight by MEPs

Ensuring that women are protected from physical, sexual or psychological abuse if they flee abroad is what lies behind the proposed European Protection Order. more »

Agatha storm lefts thousands homeless

Remnants of Tropical Storm Agatha dumped more rain across Central America, killing at least 73 people in the region, and forcing scores of others to flee their homes. more »

A pained recalling of foot-binding

Ninety-three-year old Lim Guan Siew looks back, with regret, on her experience of the long-dispelled Chinese custom of foot-binding. more »

World No Tobacco Day 2010: the Commission reaffirms its commitment to fight against smoking

Ahead of the 2010 No Tobacco Day (Monday 31st May), the European Commission unveils the results of a Eurobarometer survey which shows that a strong majority of EU citizens support stronger tobacco control measures. more »

Man swims at base of Mount Everest

Enviromentalist and endurance swimmer Lewis Pugh puts his body to the test in thin air and cold water to highlight shrinking glaciers in high mountain ranges. more »

Brazil's Dog Favela

It’s a dog’s life for the 1,500 unwanted strays who spend their days in a slum-like shelters in Brazil’s southern city of Caxias do Sul. more »

Human rights: Thailand, Burma and Pakistan

Three resolutions on the situation in Thailand, the pre-election climate in Burma and religious freedom in Pakistan were adopted by the European Parliament in Strasbourg on Thursday. more »

Chinese schools teach self-defense

Growing numbers of children enroll in kung-fu schools to learn self-defense techniques after a series of school attacks in recent weeks spark wide-spread concern in China. more »

Israeli army: gays "not an issue"

Homosexuality in the military can be a thorny issue around the world, with gay and lesbian soldiers often hiding their sexual preference out of fear. more »

EU seeks rapid ratification of UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities

European Commission Vice-President Viviane Reding will urge EU Member States to swiftly ratify the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities during a May 19 Ministers’ meeting in Zaragoza, Spain. more »